We do not find the “Passion Prediction” in Luke’s Gospel, but only general declaration about the Messiah’s suffering. In Luke 24:26 we read, “Did not the Christ have to suffer these things and then enter his glory?” On the way to the village Emmaus, Jesus reminded the disciples about His necessary suffering before He enters into the glory of His kingdom.
On each of the three occasions of the “Passion Predictions” Mark contrast Jesus’ sentiment of the Kingdom of God with that of the disciples’: Jesus was concerned with His suffering and death in His mission for the Kingdom; the disciples were preoccupied with their status and glory when the Kingdom comes.
The Disciples’ Response to Jesus’ “Passion Prediction”
Passion Predictions by Jesus Disciples’ Self-Centered Responses
Jesus’ first teaching about the Messiah’s suffering & death [8:31] Peter rebuked Jesus because he assumed that Messianic roles entail only privileges, and no suffering [8:32]
Jesus’ second teaching about the Messiah’s suffering & death [9:31-32] Disciples argued about who would be first [9:33-34]
Jesus’ third teaching about the Messiah’s suffering & death [10:33-34] James and John requested to sit with Jesus in glory (10:35-36)
In all three teachings about the Messiah’s suffering, Jesus speaks of the necessity of his rejection, suffering, and death [see Luke 24:26]; and each time the disciples responded by voicing their ambitions for status and prestige.
The first time when Jesus told His disciples about the Messiah’s suffering, Peter responded by rebuking Jesus (8:31). Peter assumed that Messianic role entails only privileges and no suffering.
In today’s passage Mark 9:30-37 when Jesus spoke of the Messiah’s suffering the second time, Mark shows the disciples’ desire for status-recognition.
When Jesus taught about the Messiah’s suffering and death the third time (10:33–34), James and John responded with a request to sit with the Messiah in Glory (10:35–45).
This summary in a caricature-maxim contrasts Jesus and the disciples: Jesus gave up His glory, in order to serve; and the disciples served, in order to gain glory.
The Disciples Did Not Understand Jesus’ Mission
32 But they did not understand what he meant and were afraid to ask him about it (Mark 9:32)
Jesus taught His disciples a second time that it is God’s will for the Son of Man [the Messiah] to suffer, die, and be raised. Once again, the disciples could not grasp: “They did not understand [what Jesus was talking about] and were afraid to ask him about it.” (8:33).
Q: Why were the disciples afraid to ask Jesus about the Messiah’s suffering?
Were they afraid that Jesus would rebuke them as He had scolded Peter earlier?
No, Jesus was not the kind of teacher who loses patience with slow learners.
On the contrary, the disciples were the kind of students who dared to rebuke their teacher. In Mark 8:32 we read that Peter took Jesus aside and ‘began to rebuke him’ for talking about suffering and dying. Peter told Jesus, “Choy! choy! choy! You better don’t anyhow say, “Die, die, die” “ ‘No Time to Die,’ Jesus.”
To the westerners, “Peter’s rebuke of Jesus” is “free speech” so all the English versions have no qualm in retaining the Greek’s literal meaning, “Peter began to rebuke Jesus” To the Chinese, a student rebuking his teacher is unthinkable, thus we read a mellow translation in the Chinese Union Version, “彼得就拉着他,劝他”. The disciples didn’t want Jesus to ruin their messianic dream, so they were afraid to ask Jesus. The truth might turn their “VR” fantasy into a nightmare.
Q: What was the disciples’ messianic dream?
A: The disciples thought that the kingdom of God was imminent [just around the corner]. Jesus was about to become king soon. God would make Jesus King when they enter Jerusalem. This expectation of glory is far from the notion of the Messiah will suffer and dies.
Q: What makes them think that Jesus would become king very soon?
[Jesus Could Do Great Miracles]
1. Jesus could perform great miracles
If the Roman army were to lay a siege on Jerusalem to curb Jewish rebellion, Jesus could solve all problems: When the food-supply is running low, Jesus could multiply the bread and the fish. If any fighter got wounded, Jesus could cause the blind to see and the lame to walk again. Anyone who bleeds profusely could just touch Jesus’ garment and the bleeding would stop. If anyone dies, Jesus could raise him back to life. Thus, with Jesus as King, the people could be liberated from a “one country, two systems” Palestine.
[Jesus Admitted that He is the Messiah]
2. Jesus had admitted to the Disciples that He is the Messiah (8:27-30).
At Caesarea Philippi, Jesus asked the disciples, “Who do you say I am?” Peter answered, “You are the Messiah!” Jesus accepted Peter’s confession, and warned the disciples not to tell anyone. That was Jesus’ indirect admission of His Messiah identity.
[Moses and Elijah Appeared with Jesus]
3. Three disciples saw Moses and Elijah with the Transfigured Jesus (9:1-9).
Peter, James and John saw the historic Moses and the power-dynamic Elijah with Jesus at Mount Herman/Mt Tabor. When a cloud enshrouded the scene and the disciples heard God declaring, “This is my Son whom I love. Listen to Him” (9:7).
Then Jesus instructed Peter, James and John not to tell anyone. Well, let’s imagine Peter. He could not sleep so he mumbled to John: “John, you awake?” John: “What?” Peter “I’m thinking about … the secret?” John: “What?” Peter: Moses and Elijah with Jesus today, lah.” John: “You talk too much … Go back to sleep” Then the other disciples said: “Goodnight, Pete. O, don’t worry, we did not hear anything.” (Snickering)
Nobody in Jesus’ time had ever seen Moses or Elijah before. The two great prophets’ appearance with Jesus was phenomenal, as if to signal the disciples something spectacular was going to happen soon.
The disciples were expecting Jesus’ coronation. They continued to daydream about the glory of the Kingdom when Jesus spoke of the Messiah’s suffering. They competed to be the first.
The disciples were apparently selective of Jesus’ teaching. They chose to listen what enjoyed but rejected the contents that is ominous to them.
Q: What about us when we read the Bible? Do we merely focus on the riches and glory of the Kingdom and ignore the teachings about the cost of following Jesus in Christian living?
There is a hymn, “The Old Rugged Cross” [composed by George Bennard in 1912]
The first line goes, “On a hill far away stood an old rugged cross. The emblem of suff’ring and shame … The last line says, “I will cling to the old rugged cross. And exchange it someday for a crown”
Christianity is not all about crowns. Christian living is pilgrimage that embraces both “suffering and crown” as we live out the will of God. All of us who follow Jesus as LORD have to face decision that put our Christian value to the test.
In 1995 Judge B. Kent of the US District Court for the Southern District of Texas stated in his ruling that any student mentioning the name of Jesus in a graduation prayer would be given a jail sentence:
And make no mistake, the court is going to have a United States Marshal in attendance at the graduation. If any student offends this court, that student will be summarily arrested and will face up to six months incarceration in the Galveston County jail of court. [Brannon House, “The People and the Agenda of Multicultural Education,” Understanding the Times, January 1997, 3].
Then in 2011 Chief District Judge Fred Biery handed down ruling that bans prayer at the graduation ceremony of the Medina Valley High School. The school to remove the terms “invocation” and “benediction” from the ceremony program and replaced with “opening remarks: and “closing remarks”. Students who are scheduled to speak may not ask the audience to “stand,” “join in prayer,” or “bow their heads,” and not to end their remarks with “amen” or in [a deity’s name] we pray. Students shall be incarcerated for contempt of Court if the injunction order is not obeyed. [Civil Action no. SA-11-CA-422-FB].
This incident did not happen in Russia but in the USA. The country’s official motto “In God We Trust” motto is evolving into “In Rights We Bow”.
33 They came to Capernaum. When he was in the house, he asked them, “What were you arguing about on the road?” 34 But they kept quiet because on the way they had argued about who was the greatest. The silence was deafening (Mark 9:33-34).
In the first Century Palestine, no ancient disciples would dare to walk ahead of their Rabbi, or even walk side by side with him. So, it is customary to see the rabbi walking first and his disciples straggling behind. As Jesus walked in front, the disciples were pushing and shoving one another, as they argued, trying to establish their respective position behind Jesus. The problem is, “Everybody wants to be the next in line after Jesus” The Disciples’ motto was “After Jesus, Second to None”.
Q: Why is the “First Position” Important to the Disciples?
The preoccupation of rank and standing were common in the Mediterranean world, particularly in Judaism.
Reach Us
+65 6223 5203